The economic downturn has been hard on all job hunters in Silicon
Valley, but those in their 40s, 50s and 60s are having an especially
tough time. Many talk about trying to hide years of experience by
removing early jobs from their résumés or by dyeing their hair.
``They're told, `What you've done and all your accomplishments
don't count for anything. Cover them up,' '' said Patti
Wilson,
founder of the Career Co.
Sometimes there are instances of outright age discrimination. But
even when older job hunters seek professional work at companies that
don't discriminate -- which by most accounts are a majority of
employers -- they still get questions about their energy, technical
skills or willingness to work long hours.
Employers may value experience, especially after the dot-com
bust. But that doesn't mean 30 years of experience will be better
received than 10 years. Some employers insist they want candidates
with three to five years of experience, not more. Career counselors
see younger workers being rehired after layoffs more quickly than
older workers.
``In some societies, age and experience are valued,'' said Pat
Stubbs, 60, who has been looking for a full-time job in
instructional design, training or knowledge management for more than
a year.
Stubbs, who lives in San Jose and is working on getting a Ph.D.,
has cut years of experience off his résumé. ``I feel like I am
forced to market myself in less than an optimal manner because of
the association of experience with age.''
Myriad factors
Research on the subject paints a mixed picture of just how
difficult it is for older workers to find jobs, whether it's getting
easier or harder, and how much of the problem stems from illegal
discrimination.
• Age discrimination complaints
from Californians to the federal Equal Employment Opportunity
Commission have risen sharply in the past three years. That doesn't
necessarily mean there's a higher rate of age discrimination; with
the aging of the baby boomers, there are more workers eligible to
file claims. Complaints filed by California workers to the state
Department of Fair Employment and Housing have shown only a mild
increase during the same time, and Santa Clara County complaints
actually dropped.
• The statewide unemployment
rate is lower for older workers than for younger ones. This could
indicate that the job market is actually better for older workers,
contrary to what many older workers report. But those who give up
looking or take low-level jobs to pay the bills aren't counted as
unemployed. And statewide numbers may not paint an accurate picture
of Silicon Valley's job market, with its emphasis on technical
skills and job mobility.
• A study of the national
high-tech workforce by the National Research Council about two years
ago found that among some groups, older workers were more likely to
lose their jobs than younger workers were. But they were just as
likely as younger workers were to find a new job within three years
of a layoff.
• A survey done several years
ago for the AARP by Marc Bendick Jr., a labor economist with Bendick
& Egan Economic Consultants, found that when companies received
résumés from similarly qualified workers of different ages, most
treated them the same, but a significant minority preferred résumés
from younger workers.
Despite concerns about age discrimination, the issue generates
relatively few lawsuits. Many companies offer severance packages to
laid-off workers in exchange for agreements that bar any legal
claims.
And while it can be difficult to prove that a layoff was
motivated by age, it can be almost impossible to prove that age
discrimination was behind a hiring decision.
`Fewer slots'
Even when illegal discrimination isn't an issue, many older
workers are at a point in their careers where finding a new job
simply isn't as easy as it was when any entry-level job would
do.
``It is a challenge. With the pyramid, there are fewer slots at
the top,'' said Marlene Williamson of Los Altos, a former vice
president of marketing with a Web services company who is in her 40s
and has been looking for a job for several months.
Williamson points out that many experienced workers are flexible
about what position or salary they receive. But companies may still
prefer someone who hasn't spent years with a higher salary or more
responsibility.
Older workers are also more likely to have spent a long time at
one company because that was a more typical career pattern when they
started working. Today, some employers may view that as a
liability.
Romano Durini, a sales and general management executive with more
than 25 years of experience who is still at pre-retirement age, said
he thinks employers see him as having ``many, many years with a
lethargic Midwestern company'' because most of his experience was at
one non-Silicon Valley technology company -- even though he spent
most of his time in California and later worked for a start-up.
Durini has been job hunting and consulting for about six months.
Winning bosses over
Some observers say older workers have to overcome employers'
misgivings about them.
Employers ``look at the younger workers as having more recent
skills, being more recently educated and having more energy and
productivity,'' said Sue LaForge, project director for the National
Council on the Aging Work Centers for Santa Clara and Santa Cruz
counties.
`Nothing to hide'
The solution for many older workers is to keep trying until they
find an employer that is open to -- or even appreciates -- their
experience.
David Koo, 51, of Fremont, said that during his six-month job
search, he was sometimes told that he was overqualified. But he
recently found a job doing auditing work for a landscaping
company.
Some remain hopeful that potential employers will value their
experience.
Shomir Dighe, 50, of Sunnyvale has been looking for an
engineering and program management job for several months.
He has resisted advice to cut his early experience off his
résumé, partly because some of his earlier work is relevant to what
he's looking for.
``I worked for 12 years on one program alone, and I'm really
proud of it,'' Dighe said. ``I have nothing to hide.''
A final frustration for some older job hunters, especially those
nearing retirement age, is to be told that they need to find new
careers.
``I'm certainly capable of doing that,'' Stubbs said. ``I don't
have time to do that. What would you have me start over
as?''